Pages

21 February 2012

Mass prayers

The new edition of the prayers during the Holy Mass have some modifications, mostly on the part of the Priest, than of the faithful. However there are two responses that have not gone well with me. One is the answer to the Priests statement, 'The Lord is with you'. The new response is 'And with your spirit'. The earlier one, I feel, was much more holistic: 'And also with you'.

The other is the final prayer before Holy Communion. It is the Centurion's words when Jesus volunteers to come to his house to heal his servant. The prayer ends thus, "... and my spirit shall be healed." The earlier version: "... and I shall be healed."

The basic reason for my preference for the former version in these aspects is that the newer version smacks of Platonic/Augustinian dualism: body-spirit dichotomy. Rather than look at the whole person, the focus is primarily on the spirit/soul. One may say that the word is inclusive... then why not use an inclusive word, rather than camouflage it?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...