The article appearing on The Times of India online edition about the historical record of Ayodhya as a place of worship offers a reading which should be the basis on which any rational decision should be arrived at, with regard to issues whenever in dispute. However, we often resort to every means other than checking records. Primarily because we don't have records!!
The article also makes interesting reading... how we come to know of Indian history from people who were not from India! The article does well to explicitly state:
I think we Indians have a sort of allergy to put pen to paper! We prefer the verbal testimony and that is how we think history should be recorded! We really didn't learn very well from Valmiki, the first author, poet of the Ramayana. If only we inherited his keen sense of recording history, in black and white, we would have had a better chance at being more 'educated'. The same Valmiki is also credited with teaching the children of Rama and Sita the verbal song of the Ramayana. Thus blessing us with both the verbal and written history record. So later if there is any discrepancy between the two, the point of departure can well be traced and reasons for the same known - if people after Valmiki did what Valmiki did! Even if they did not, at least we have the original document for further and future reference.
The article also makes interesting reading... how we come to know of Indian history from people who were not from India! The article does well to explicitly state:
The British officials of the period demonstrated the opposite of the well-known Indian disregard for documentation.The article spells out how worship at Ayodhya was a joint-worship of Hindus and Muslims... peacefully and in perfect harmony... till 1857! Besides the religious - or call it politicized religious - issue what makes interesting reading is the historical data provided. And who recorded that data!
I think we Indians have a sort of allergy to put pen to paper! We prefer the verbal testimony and that is how we think history should be recorded! We really didn't learn very well from Valmiki, the first author, poet of the Ramayana. If only we inherited his keen sense of recording history, in black and white, we would have had a better chance at being more 'educated'. The same Valmiki is also credited with teaching the children of Rama and Sita the verbal song of the Ramayana. Thus blessing us with both the verbal and written history record. So later if there is any discrepancy between the two, the point of departure can well be traced and reasons for the same known - if people after Valmiki did what Valmiki did! Even if they did not, at least we have the original document for further and future reference.
No comments:
Post a Comment